www.quake.ie  

discord - the Ireland Gaming Club  
IEGC - www.irelandgamingclub.com  
Ireland Gaming Club - facebook  

Quake Live Server - quake.hagfish.ing  


search  
 quake.ie | anonymous | login | register

quake.ie columns The Verdict
 30/10/2005 04:03  The Verdict39565 views | 40 replies 
Illkillya
James Galvin


Entering a world of pain
clan : fish heads

posts : 892
site administrator
ive donated to quake.ie!


Its good - needs some work but for straight out of the box it’s well done. I like the movement… still trying to grasp that slidy thing myself, although I found some cool movement today (which most of ye probably new about already) on The Fragging Yard – going over the bounce pad from shards towards LG, rather than crouch sliding, just let go of forward and as you land off the bounce pad you’re launched into bunnyhopping type movement, and you can maintain a very high speed, sliding not necessary, strafing optional.

The maps are a bit dodgy, but I don’t want to judge them until I’ve played them in 4v4 and seen how the strategies develop. I think CPM4 would be very well suited to Q4, I hope that’s on the way. 1v1 isn’t bad; less of the boring game of concentration and armour stacking than in Q3 1v1, but it badly needs some new maps.

As for the net code… the jury is still out on that one. Railgun is extremely accurate online – I had a game of Q3 with sol the other day and was amazed by the amount of shots that clearly should have been hits but weren’t. In Q4 I usually find that if I aimed right, I hit the guy. Getting stuck to the spot when the ping spikes a bit is not really acceptable. There are too many problems with ISDN, and I fear that this could be decisive in FH’s first season. Too many players on the server gets far too laggy.

Q4 doesn’t really feel like a whole new game to me… it’s more like that time when all the new maps got released in Q3… ospdm5 and ospdm6, etc., and FH and nD had a LAN to learn them. It was refreshing to see new strategies being developed, and how it took some time for people to realize that primary area on osp5 is actually railgun. It brought a new lease of life to the game imo, even though I was always more of a dm6, dm7, dm14, cpm4 fan. Q4 is a bit like that… the game is similar enough and most of the dedicated Q3ers are there, but the canvas is clear and we have a new palette.

Needs:
Full brights
Forcemodel
Teamplay locations
True lightning
The ability to see who is ready or not ready on a server (have I missed something here?)
Ability to lock your team (perhaps I missed that also?)

Wants:
Team overlay
Proper flags – what the hell are those glowing things?
Drawspeed
Simple items
Damage given / received stats
Clanarena
Cpm4
Q3dm6

I’m slightly disappointed by the relatively small player base in Ireland. I’m glad there are at least a few future superstars playing the game, with a bit of luck they’ll stick with it and not be lured away by CoD2 or anything. Hopefully quetzal’s clan will get off the ground, and maybe we’ll see something of xLh the Lithuanian-Irish clan based in Dublin.

Jolt leagues, when are you starting?

Clanbase has got it right this time around… the deals they made with the Americans has paved the way for Quake4 to measure up to its predecessor.
Q4 TDM: $25,000 with $12,500 to the first place winners.
Q4 1v1: $15,000 with $7.500 to the first place winner.

With the game just a week old, this is exactly the slap in the face needed for all the top Q3 clans wondering whether to fizzle out or make the effort again, and a greater incentive for l33t pro gaming clans (pcw now have server highskillers only plz) of CoD, RTCW, ET, BF2, MOH and all those other realistic games now in their twilight. Clanbase has put Quake right back where it belongs – second only to Counter Strike.

With the CPL having unveiled Q4 as their main game long before it was even released, and Paddy Power offering odds of 1/100 on its inclusion in the WCG, for its debut season at least, Q4 will be a success.

While these big tournaments don’t hold any particular interest for me (unless I know somebody competing), they foster an enthusiasm and a competitive spirit at every level. As we saw in Q3… once these tournaments disappear, apathy sets in. The big clans realize they have nothing to play for… why should they make a special effort to win a Eurocup with nothing to gain but a little golden cup icon, 16x13pixels and only 592bytes. The little guys have nothing to aim for.

In God’s master plan every living thing has a function in bringing a balance to nature. The oxpecker eats ticks and other parasites off the backs of cattle and rhinoceros, while the trochilus will clear the leeches from the open mouth of a crocodile. Similarly, on a server near you, observe the ultra-competitive 15-year-old Dutch guys, with spiked hair (dyed blonde at the tips) who dominate the pickups at 10am on a Sunday morning, bursting with enthusiasm… crying themselves to sleep at night after losing a duel, forever sapping the joy from game. Though their continued presence drags the game lower and lower till it begins to resemble a half-life mod, paradoxically these guys who threaten to destroy the game are the very ones who sustain it. As long as our servers are home to the familiar hooting of the greater spotted m1rv, the constant cries of ‘n00b’ echoing through their hollow lives can always remind us that the game still lives.

Quake’s greatest asset is the balance in the community. In other games, the proportion of pokemon n1njas is so high that it is almost impossible to enjoy any competitive fixtures without resorting to team chat only. Quake will never reach that saturation point; simply because far too many of us are no longer in secondary school. The problem is that when the big tournaments do end, and the enthusiasm from the kids begins to wane, you’re left with a lot of part timers who don’t practise, don’t play on publics, and aren’t particularly interested in learning new maps.

Last time I checked, there were 56 clans signed up for the Q4 TDM Opencup. I was interested to see how this compared to other games, and it did OK for something that was just released. While I looked at the signups I was surprised by the lack of Irish teams. I’ll compare with some other countries: Finland, Croatia, and Slovenia. Croatia and Finland have a similar population to Ireland but a bit larger, while Slovenia has about half our population.

ET 6V6: – 238 clans registered
Croatia 0
Ireland 0
Finland 22
Slovenia 3

UT CTF: – 67 clans registered
Croatia 3
Ireland 0
Finland 1
Slovenia 0

CoD S&D: – 243 clans registered
Croatia 2
Ireland 0
Finland 12
Slovenia 16

MOHAA OBJ: – 133 clans registered
Croatia 0
Ireland 0
Finland 8
Slovenia 0

UT2K4 TDM: – 52 clans registered
Croatia 1
Ireland 0
Finland 0
Slovenia 1

BF2 Conquest: – 124 clans registered
Croatia 1
Ireland 0
Finland 3
Slovenia 0

CS:Source: – 213 clans registered
Croatia 2
Ireland 0
Finland 30
Slovenia 2


Slightly worried at this stage, I’ve seen teams from Cyprus and Malta but still nothing from Ireland.


CS 1.6 :– 269 clans registered
Croatia 1
Ireland 1
Finland 95
Slovenia 1

WOOHOO an Irish clan, Wink – it’s even got a few Cork men in it. They’ve got a q4 icon next to the name too… does this mean you’ll be playing q4 as a clan Tazzle?

F.E.A.R. came out the same day in Ireland as it did in Slovenia… why do they have more teams than us playing it? I think we must be the worst represented European country on Clanbase. For the rainiest country in Europe, you think we’d have a bit more of an online games scene. Just look at CS… Ireland’s most commonly played game by far afaik, and we can only manage 1 team in Clanbase. Finland has 95 teams signed up so far this season for CS 1.6, and another 30 for source. More signups from this one country in this one game than in all of the Quakes put together probably. For a country the size of Ireland in terms of population, it is hard to imagine. We have a grand total of 1 clan signed up in all of the games I checked out there. This clan has a grand total of 6 members. And even at that, it turns out that I actually bump into one of these guys occasionally in real life. Can you imagine the scene with over 100 clans playing the game?

I never would have thought that our mini gaming community here was actually flying the flag for Irish gaming as a whole in Europe. I always assumed that Quake’s day was over. Quetzal et al - its just another reason for ye to get your teams sorted so that we can preserve this last vestige of Ireland’s clan scene, which must have just melted into the UK scene sometime while I wasn’t looking. Did I dream up the 14+ Irish CS teams… was it really that long ago? I went into a couple of the Cork gaming internet cafes this summer and there was such a booming LAN CS scene in this small city alone that there were entire clans playing in the cafes. Did everyone just get bored of it?

Q3 at its height had something over 100 TDM clans signed up for the Open Cup. At this early stage, it looks promising that Q4 has already got 56 signups… I would expect that a lot of teams are having trouble getting their dozier members to sort out their GUIDs, or their cheapskate members to fork out for the game (hi Vin) and haven’t yet been able to sign up as a result. I would expect the tally to rise to 80 or so for the TDM, which is fairly healthy. It sees the return of many big names from aAa and EYE to smr and D&M.

As for CTF… it started off slowly in Q3, developed into something that most TDM clans played “for fun”, before surprising nearly everyone by overtaking TDM to become the bigger mode towards the end of Q3’s lifetime. There was always something about CTF that made it seem frivolous, and again in Quake4 it has really only attracted a handful of those Q3 teams that didn’t play any TDM. It could be fun, especially if players learn to improve on the fancy movement, crouchsliding and ramp jumping and bunnyhopping. I hope they wake up and make it 4v4 though.

For the first time we’re introduced to big names from other games like CoD, with a lot of the signups having Eurocup medals in other games… probably indicating that they’re super l33t multigaming clan with sponsors who sends everyone a new mousemat twice a year. A lot of these guys refer to themselves as pro gamers… there’s dozens of them in #q4.uk. Their goal in life is to collect enough screenshots and irc logs to prove that everyone else is a n00b. When they begin to irritate me I just remember the oxpecker and everything is OK.

 
edited by Illkillya on 30/10/2005 04:03 

page : 1 2
30/10/2005 22:14#21
[spectator]
Laurent Humblet




posts : 222
administrator


and DeD wouldnt play us because they were missing Zonic

Aaaaah comon killy, we werent that bad were we?

What about having 3-4 irish servers up and running 24/7 and advertise it on Quake.ie, top-right corner like any other server info? Having the #quake.ie channel advertised on the server when connecting, etc? That might help for Q4 anyway.
 
 

31/10/2005 03:01#22
OverLord
Dave Woodlock



clan : n8z

posts : 191
administrator


ded right spec
 
 

31/10/2005 07:34#23
RevHellfire
rev




posts : 19


While its certainly early days as far as Quake IV is concerned, the uptake is not looking good. Personally I feel that Quake 3 did a lot of damage to the Quake name (no no dont shoot me down just yet), most Quake II players really just didnt take to it. Quake IV seems more like Quake II to me which is a good thing so hopefully more people will be encourged to play it, and while it may be easier to kill in it (this doesnt seem to apply to me as anyone who has played me will testify) this is a good thing for the casual player who wants to get some positive feedback in a game.

I personally think that irish gaming online is much larger that people suspect, but there is are a few major differinces between now and say the late 90s.
Firstly more games, people are spread out over many many more games.
Secondly with dsl quite the number of people now dont even play on irish servers with uk/european ones offering similar pings.

I think putting up more servers isnt going to make a difference, Im more than willing to put up servers, the problem is getting people to use them.
I think if you want to increase the number of players you have a available to you youll need to start running your own league and look further than boards.ie for recruits. Youd be amazed at the number of irish online whove never heard of it yet play games heavily. Actually it may be worthwhile for eric to attempt to recreate the old ign (or something simlar) and provide a focus point for irish gaming again.
 
 

31/10/2005 08:49#24
OverLord
Dave Woodlock



clan : n8z

posts : 191
administrator


good points rev
 
 

31/10/2005 16:12#25
quetzal
Ownerer.




posts : 80


Re: the trickjump nights and newbie-teaching, Ill do the latter once (assuming) I get good enough and the same with the trickjumps, though Giblets owning the trick-discovery scene at the moment
 
 

31/10/2005 17:45#26
bAz
bAz


hurray for chess(e)

posts : 288


or DeD and FH never having 5 at the same time
 
 

31/10/2005 19:05#27
melachi
Nasty fucker




posts : 257
administrator


I know that there are quite a bit of "online pc gamers", its just that the majority arent into competitive play/communities. There are better games than quake for just going on a public server and playing for fun. Nothing is as good for competitive scene play though but this is something which is harder to get into than jumping onto a battlefield 2 server
 
 

31/10/2005 20:03#28
Rapier
Rapp



clan : n8z

posts : 278
administrator


Solution to not having many irish gamers is for companies to advertise gaming like you see in other countries - germany and holland being a good example where you see DSL being targeted at gamers with low ping etc. (fastpath) however no one has got that ball rolling yet as it would probably be a big risk.

I reckon consoles are fairly popular here and now that u can play console games online i reckon thats what most newcomers are doing, lot less expensive isnt it with no absolute cocks calling you a noob when its your first time on a server. I dont know how many times ive seen whats defo a total noob come onto an ET server and kicked voted out because he sucks but the irony lies in the fact this guy/girl probably has a real life and hasnt lived online like the rest of the fucktards outhere.
 
 

01/11/2005 09:06#29
Jedi
jedi




posts : 240
administrator


Your correct about the amount of people playing consoles. Thers also some pretty sweet prises in ireland for the console games. A group got sent to england flights and accomodation paid for to play fifa last year. Reminds me of when we went to cologne, england for the quake 3.

GameCon is the lan where you see most of the consolers.
 
 

01/11/2005 12:46#30
Dardoz
Darren


ut>q?
clan : n8z

posts : 164


Ive been trying to help the noobs a bit. I emailed a few of those lads who are signed up to CB 1v1. Just to make sure they know about this site as well as #quake.ie on quakenet. From what I can see, a fair few lads are coming from other games but they may not know about the quake community here.
 
 

01/11/2005 13:01#31
Zero
Ronan Condon


Absolute Fucking Champion
clan : n8z

posts : 816
site administrator


i think for a start, everyone should slobber all over quetzals new clan (http://www.quake.ie/post.asp?item=1792), i.e. help them out where you can, root out members for it etc. a new clan does 100 times more for the scene than a hundred other things.
 
 

01/11/2005 18:42#32
Spaceman
Paddy Conway


The Dude Abides
clan : fish heads

posts : 266
administrator


what about ded reforming also?? STORY BENJI Baz Casc?
 
edited by Spaceman on 01/11/2005 18:42 

04/11/2005 16:46#33
saik
mr.nobody




posts : 242


i have never actually seen the game.

you were able to run quake and quake2 and quake3 on 3 year old pcs when they came out, and they had cutting edge graphics wise when you had the cash for the right machine. on top of that the other games were shite compared to them.

cs and all those other games, basically WAR, are deadly ideas. id have prefered to play a cool game with spitfires and tanks and real guns instead of some watered down star trek crap. unless the star trek game had some totally amazing blood and guts.

they should have put in a facility for gambling on duels, people did that ages ago on some website. they didnt do much of a job putting in the multiplayer stuff, or bots. i dont see the harm in throwing in all the old decent maps either if they are too lazy to make new ones. they managed to make the consoles work with quake3 and they have hard drives now some of them so you can patch them too.

id and raven have serious money behind them and had an opportunity to take over here and they werent arsed. why the hell arent they making a netcode engine that you can stick a shite graphics engine on and play on anything. its a converted single player game as far as im concerned.

id consider a large investment in computer hardware to go and play this game a total waste of entertainment money.

as regards the level of interest im amazed that there is any at all. if you want a new batch of players youll have to go looking for them. and theyll have to be young and stupid, can you see anyone over the age of 20 being brainwashed into competitive quake?

all a bit negative. im just very bitter that i cant go and play

ps the new site is cool
 
edited by saik on 04/11/2005 16:47 

04/11/2005 18:24#34
bAz
bAz


hurray for chess(e)

posts : 288


Star Trek Elite Force was pretty nifty, I however have played Quake4, and to me it doesnt justify an upgrade to play it in total splendor. Youre right about Quake3 playing on more or less any old PC.


 
 

04/11/2005 19:18#35
OverLord
Dave Woodlock



clan : n8z

posts : 191
administrator


well i dont know what pcs you guys had (saik and baz) but quake 2 crawled on my pc (p133 16mb ram) when it came out in 1998? and quake 3 crawled on my pc (p3 450 tnt 2). 1999-00. Its the same old cliches trotted out about a new game.
 
 

04/11/2005 23:52#36
Illkillya
James Galvin


Entering a world of pain
clan : fish heads

posts : 892
site administrator
ive donated to quake.ie!


Im with ol on this one - q3test was released in October 1999 or so... I really dont think a 1996 computer would have run it very well, and even on my l33t 1999 Gateway Performance 450 with voodoo3 (a very good PC at the time) I didnt have 125fps solid.

And I didnt even bother with quake2 on my 1995 486dx @100mhz, since even quake1 struggled on that.

I think q4 is as good as its predecessors in this regard, you dont need a completely top of the range PC, and if they unlock those lighting cvars then it looks like any decent machine would do the trick.

Saik I think you might like q4 since nearly all the q2ers Ive seen around seem very happy with it. And The Edge is the main map again.
 
 

05/11/2005 00:14#37
Vinnit
eamo


.
clan : fish heads

posts : 164


ah voodoo3 what a great card that was, could play q3 with it today if you wanted. Also im with ol and killy on this one, i think dan and baz are looking back with rose tinted glasses or something. q3 didnt run any faster than q4 when it came out afaik. My pc is heading towards 18 months old and i get constant 63fps in q4.
 
 

05/11/2005 01:12#38
Searrard
GerW


who?

posts : 35


I have signed up for the CB 1v1... at the moment Im content to play public the reason for this is that if i did start into CTF/TDM proper Id end up losing the rag with the PC and breaking the keyboard/mouse/punching the monitor...

I need the brightskins, teamplay locations & forcemodel... on anydetail, I find it extremely hard to spot an opponent due to my nystagmus* (unless they are moving or shooting)

Unless there is someway to change the quality of textures on a lvl without changing the quality on a player (Halflife 1 engine has this to some degree) then I generally flying around like a gimped T-Rex...

*nystagmus (constantly uncontrolled eye movement). Nystagmus is very common among people that are partially sighted. The consequences of this is limitations in the ability to interpret visual information... I might have a wider field of vision (left to right) but I have to concentrate a hell of a lot more to recognise an enemy in q4... unlike q3 where it was "Its green... shoot it!"
 
 

05/11/2005 15:22#39
RevHellfire
rev




posts : 19


I think the issue most quake II players have had with the game to date is the maps, theyre.. how shall I say it.. not great. The edge remake is just terrible, far to compressed, it all seems just a bit to much on top of you hopefully someone will relase a version with the same scale as the q2dm1.
I havent tried CTF yet but the release of the lokis minions themed maps for q3 almost would get me to install that game again. Hopefully that will get ported to q4

 
 

10/11/2005 19:03#40
Jazzy
Andrew


a gangsta rapper of love

posts : 18


Well in fairness i would be a well known UT head and im willing to jump into quake 4, just a matter of funding atm... i is broke :(
btw there is a couple of Irish UT clans on clanbase.. u just didnt look hard enough (its tricky cos we are called different things), on the TAM ladder (very popular gametype atm, sorta flavour of the month tho) we are currently 19th (mid table) in the europe wide league, thats unreal.ie btw, we are ahead of Kammehs clan which is always good and have an undefeated streak of 6 in a row (7 after tonite ) also there is Interrobang?! which nag is part of for the 2v2 TDM ladder and me and Mang87s 99 Mega Turquoise Bananas Floating In A Summer Sky 2v2 team (thats 99MTBFIASS for short, ridiculous and stupid i know, but that was the point). alot of the UT ppl atm though are dedicated to thier game and just waiting till 2007 comes out really. a few, like naitkris, have switched over and im deffo gonna play u guys once i have it, played JonnyNew/AK47 at a LAN in Q3 1v1 tourney mod and i f**kin loved it (never played quake with brightskins etc.). i was always a quaker at heart but could never play online cos of my bro (Astrofool on boards.ie, used to play TFC for RvR... taking all the ISDN bandwidth grrr). used to love it at lans tho and the 1v1 aspect was cool. plus quake was the originator of campgrounds .

neway back to the point.... i tend to ramble
alot of irelands gaming community have become very specialised, if they play CS its ONLY CS, ut for ut etc.
this makes us as a community look smaller than we actually are.i would consider myself a multigamer, ill play anything really from almost ne genre, but id say ppl like me make up about 5% of the gamers here in ireland. we (ireland) are the most succesful country in the world for the Playstation brand, we actually have one of the biggest (per capita wise) gaming markets in europe. this along with broadband becoming more easily availible obviously means an increase in online gamers. The problem as i see it is that alot of the communities are already set up. UIE, QIE, the CSS scene etc. already have established clans with a niche of elite players who play on clanbase etc.
now consider this in sport - if u like to play football it doesnt neccasarily mean ur going to play in the premier league does it? so then of course things like pub teams and sunday league teams are born and play competitivly but not on the same level as the chelskis of the world.
But how would one go about creating such things for gamers and our humble community?
The idea of room101.org i think is a fantastic one for LAN organising and I have been pimping it to ppl i know to use it etc. the more im going to LANs the more my gaming mates are coming with me, i have trouble nowadays when i go to gamecon cos there is so much ppl i know who i want to talk to that often i feel like im leaving ppl out or cant get a game in. This of course is only a good thing, but the problem is that they see sorta segragated teams and such. last LAN i was at i brought a mate who was new to the whole LAN scene and when he saw the 1st-IB lads all huddled together it came accross to him as somewhat hostile cos they would be on the same team and sitting beside each other and he was like "they are here to win". of course there was no hostility in reality but it just came accross that way for him.
An idea I would propose to fix this sorta thing and the whole mess of gaming in Ireland is sort of a room101.org site except for games, like clanbase but local if ya get me. instead of facing nameless germans and such u would be facing a clan from college x or county y or just random mates z. it would be competitive but not to the elite degrees of CB. gamers from all different creeds and games could talk and discuss yet still play competitivly on their chosen game. i mean the only real place where i can talk to gamers online is the boards.ie games forum and LAN paries one to some degree, aside from that its the unreal heads over at uie.

nehow, sorry for making a very long post and such, but to sum up - Sunday league ftw!
 
 
page : 1 2
you must be logged in to post replies.
click here to login.
click here to become a member.
click here to search.